Transformational Research, Science and Technology workshop summary

Hosted by the Ministry of Research Science and Technology, Nelson 2-3 August 2006

Summary & Next Steps

Transformational RS&T workshop

  • Nelson: 2-3 August 2006
  • 35 participants: mix of individuals from RS&T, government and private sector
  • Aim: –Foster discussion on transformational RS&T –Identify up to 15 concepts for MoRST to take to Ministers

The challenge…

  • Where can additional RS&T make a real difference to what matters to New Zealand?
  • This workshop is a new approach to identifying ideas drawing on collective wisdom and diversity.

[Helen Anderson, Chief Executive, MoRST Opening Address]

Transformational RS&T...

  • Likely to have a strong outcome focus
  • Relates to opportunities for new investment or effort: doing more or doing it differently
  • Likely to involve:
    • Close partnerships of scientists and users:
    • Multi-organisation; co-funding
    • An integrated mix of different types of RS&T: basic, strategic, applied, transdisciplinary
    • IP or unique know-how
    • Strong international focus
    • Mix of existing and new effort

Responses from workshop participants to the challenge …

  • ‘Transformational RS&T is about science connecting to users’
  • ‘Why look at capital going in – instead look at the return coming out. ‘
  • ‘Not enough pull – we’re pushing on a piece of string.’
  • ‘Science needs to look to future but also needs to resonate with New Zealanders.’

The Concepts …

  • Prior to workshop 80 concepts (up to 2 pages long) received from individuals from government departments, CRIs, universities.
  • Some authors present at workshop; some not.
  • Each outlined:
    • An opportunity or challenge for New Zealand
    • The critical contribution or role that New Zealand RS&T could make
    • Evidence that RS&T could meet the opportunity or challenge
    • Required changes
  • Most focused on the ‘what’ (areas of RS&T) not the ‘how’ (approaches to doing RS&T)
  • Workshop task: to select top 15 advising how they could be strengthened further and implemented.

Criteria

Two criteria used to support discussions and scoring of concepts:

  1. Importance of outcome for New Zealand
  2. Contribution of additional NZ RS&T

The Concepts: overview from workshop participants …

  • Most incremental and not transformational
  • But useful early ideas
  • Need to find the synergies across concepts
  • Need to articulate the unique New Zealand approach
  • Need to consider the ‘hows’
  • A few gaps: social, manufacturing, health, artificial intelligence, tidal energy, …

Top 14 Concepts (identified by workshop participants)

  • Innovation led manufacturing – technology platforms
  • Future foods (functional and premium foods)
  • Real time feedback for efficient ecology and productivity (expert system production and resource management)
  • ICT driven risk management (biosecurity)
  • New Zealand response to climate change (adaptation)
  • Next generation bioreactors (rumen based value-added products)
  • Marine biotechnology/biodiscovery
  • Personalised therapeutics (niche manufacturing, pharmaceuticals)
  • Integrated environmental technologies
  • Urban ecosystems
  • Smart biomaterials
  • Money from muck (extracting value from primary sector waste streams)
  • Enhancing our natural environment to be profitable and green
  • Health – evidence and tools for New Zealand specific health issues

Implementation ideas: the how

  • Connect globally and bring in external ideas
  • Vibrant cities and profitable and green environment will naturally attract talent
  • Tailored governance models can support links between RS&T and business
  • Variable co-funding enabling RS&T to explore frontier ideas
  • Improved institutional arrangements
  • Infuse science into firms and sectors: then no need for technology transfer

Next steps

  • Develop and present concepts to Ministers in September
  • Include in RS&T strategy in 2007

About Attachments...

Page updated 09 Nov 2007